News

Florida Man Accused of Mailing Peanut Butter Card to Woman With Severe Allergy

Plantation police arrested Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr. over a greeting card allegedly smeared with peanut butter and mailed to a woman with a severe allergy.

Aerial view toward Plantation, Florida, from neighboring Sunrise
An aerial view toward Plantation from Sunrise, Florida. Location context, not the alleged victim's home or the incident. Photo: Yanjipy / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

A greeting card allegedly smeared with peanut butter has led to criminal charges against a Florida man accused of targeting someone he knew had a severe peanut allergy.

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, was arrested on November 13, 2026. Plantation police said the investigation concerned mail received more than a year earlier, on August 14, 2025.

He faces charges of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence. The accusations have not been proven in court. ABC News reported the arrest and the department's statement.

What the woman reported

According to police-report details published by USA TODAY Network via AOL, the woman noticed a blue envelope that looked greasy and carried unfamiliar handwriting.

Inside was a greeting card with a brown substance she recognized as peanut butter. She dropped it, went inside and washed her hands.

The woman reported developing hives and tingling in her arms that lasted about six hours. Her identity has been withheld in the reports.

These are the symptoms described in this individual case. The reporting does not establish that she suffered anaphylactic shock or was hospitalized.

Aerial view toward Plantation, Florida, from neighboring Sunrise
An aerial view toward Plantation from Sunrise, Florida. Location context, not the alleged victim's home or the incident. Photo: Yanjipy / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

How investigators say they traced the envelope

ABC News reported that investigators used a 15-digit number associated with the envelope's postage stamps to trace their purchase.

According to the booking report described by ABC, the postal machine takes photographs during transactions. Police said a kiosk photograph helped identify the alleged sender.

USA TODAY Network reported that the stamps had been purchased with a payment card belonging to Cancellare. The envelope also used a fictitious sender name and false return address, according to the police report.

Those findings form part of the authorities' case; they are not a court determination of guilt.

The recipient told investigators that Cancellare had been married to her best friend and that she had known him for roughly 20 years.

Police alleged that he blamed her for the breakdown of the marriage. The woman said he knew about her allergy because they had repeatedly dined together, when she needed to explain the precautions required.

Law&Crime's account of the probable-cause affidavit describes that alleged relationship and motive.

Archival view in Plantation, Florida
Plantation, Florida. Archival location context, not a photograph of the alleged crime or anyone involved. Photo: William “Patrick” Ma… / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Charges and bond

Initial reporting put Cancellare's bond at $20,000. Law&Crime subsequently reported that he had posted bond and been released.

ABC News said on November 16 that it had not immediately identified an attorney representing him.

The case remains an allegation to be tested through the criminal justice process. Its central question is whether investigators can prove that the card was deliberately sent with knowledge of the recipient's dangerous allergy.

Image credits: Plantation aerial view, Yanjipy, CC BY-SA 4.0; Plantation location photograph, William “Patrick” Ma…, CC BY-SA 3.0. Both photographs provide city context and do not show the alleged victim, suspect, card or incident.

Be the first to react

Most read today

  1. Beyond the SpotlightWhat Happened to Yanni The Quiet Life of Yiannis Chryssomallis After Fame~4.3k reads today
  2. Explore AmericaA Newborn Baby Appeared to Have a Full Moustache. The Viral Video Has People Asking If It's Real.~4.2k reads today
  3. Trending News115 Workers Were Aboard an Oil Rig When It Sank Off Gabon. Five Are Still Unaccounted For.~4.1k reads today
  4. Explore AmericaBorn Without Arms or Legs, He Raised Two Daughters With His Mother's Help. Years Later, His Daughter Came Home for Him.~4k reads today
  5. Explore AmericaHe Ate at the Same Restaurant for 10 Years. When He Stopped Showing Up, a Chef Saved His Life.~3.9k reads today
  6. Trending NewsFlight Attendant Helps Exhausted Mom and Baby in Moment Captured by Fellow Passenger~3.7k reads today
  7. Celeb NewsRFK's Granddaughter Kyle Kennedy Dies at 42 After a Life Devoted to Education and Advocacy~3.5k reads today
  8. Trending NewsPresley Gerber Video Reportedly Shows Night Before His Death at Santa Monica Rehab~3.5k reads today