Vice President JD Vance responded to a ABC News This Week segment in which six Democratic lawmakers argued that service members can and must disobey unlawful orders under the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ). Vance reposted the interview clip on X and wrote: “If the president hasn\’t issued illegal orders, then telling the military to defy the president is by definition illegal.”
The video features Senators Elissa Slotkin and Mark Kelly and Representatives Maggie Goodlander, Chris Deluzio, Chrissy Houlahan, and Jason Crow—six lawmakers with military or intelligence backgrounds advocating clarity on legality under the UCMJ. Newsweek coverage notes the debate centers on what constitutes an unlawful order.
Trump responded with a harsh line, calling the actions “seditious behavior” and threatening punishment; White House aides said he was not ordering executions and that orders from the commander in chief remain lawful. White House statements and subsequent briefings emphasized the chain of command.
Experts cite the UCMJ principle that service members disobey unlawful commands, a standard shaped by the Nuremberg Trials. Slotkin and fellow lawmakers say the clip was a warning to seek legal guidance when questions arise about deployments and national security.
The clash touches on broader questions of civil-military relations, constitutional authority, and how political rhetoric can affect trust in the military. Observers note ongoing tensions over National Guard deployments in Democratic cities and related foreign-strike operations.
Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you make a purchase through the ads.